Religious liberty at SCOTUS, again: Touch, comfort and the prayers of clergy at executions

The U.S. Supreme Court will hear religious freedom arguments Tuesday in the case of a Texas death-row inmate named John Henry Ramirez.

Ramirez, 37, wants his Southern Baptist pastor to lay hands on him and pray before and during his execution. The state of Texas won’t allow it.

Time magazine’s Madeleine Carlisle provides a nice overview of the case.

“The job of a minister is not to stand still and be quiet,” Dana Moore, the inmate’s pastor, tells Time. “Prayer is very important. And the power of touch is real. It’s encouraging. It brings peace. It’s significant… Why can’t I hold his hand?”

In an August interview with New York Times religion writer Ruth Graham, Ramirez took responsibility for killing Corpus Christi convenience store clerk Pablo Castro, calling Castro’s 2004 death a “heinous murder.” (As noted by the Corpus Christi Caller-Times, Ramirez “beat and kicked Castro and stabbed him 29 times with a 6-inch serrated knife.” He and two female accomplices left the scene with $1.25.)

“It would just be comforting,” Ramirez said of wanting Moore by his side at the time of his lethal injection.

At The Associated Press, religion writer David Crary explains that the “ACLU has a long history of opposing the death penalty and also says that condemned prisoners, even at the moment of execution, have religious rights.”

Conservative church-state activists have been involved in this case, and others like it, since Day 1.

“Intriguingly, the ACLU’s position in the Ramirez case is echoed by some conservative religious groups which support the death penalty and are often at odds with the ACLU on other issues,” Crary reports.

For more on the case, see coverage by Christianity Today’s Daniel Silliman, the Baptist Standard’s Ken Camp and AP’s Juan A. Lozano.

Power Up: The Week’s Best Reads

1. God and guns: In a compelling piece for FiveThirtyEight, veteran religion writer Kimberly Winston presents “a tale of two pastors and two mass shootings.”

She contrasts the different responses to tragedy and trauma by Mother Emanuel African American Episcopal Church in Charleston, South Carolina, and the First Baptist Church of Sutherland Springs, Texas.

2. Faith groups increasingly join fight against climate change: My favorite Associated Press tag team — religion writer Luis Andres Henao and videographer Jessie Wardarski — go on a boat ride along a Louisiana bayou.

The purpose: to report on “a broader trend around the world of faith leaders and environmental activists increasingly joining the fight against climate change.”

CONTINUE READING: “Touch, Prayer And The Role Of Clergy At Executions: SCOTUS Weighs Religious Freedom” by Bobby Rose, Jr., at Religion Unplugged.


Please respect our Commenting Policy